Obesity and weight difficulties are often over simplified, blamed on lack of willpower, personal responsibility, or lifestyle choices. This framing not only misrepresents the science, but it also fuels stigma that can harm physical and mental health. Modern research tells a far more complex story. Obesity is a chronic, multifactorial condition shaped by biology, environment, psychology, and social context.
Understanding this complexity is essential if we are to respond with compassion, effectiveness, and evidence-based care.
Obesity Is Not a Personal Failure
At its core, obesity reflects changes in body fat regulation but those changes are not simply the result of "eating too much” or "moving too little.” The human body has evolved powerful systems to defend energy stores, and for many individuals, these systems work against sustained weight loss.
When body weight decreases, the brain responds by increasing hunger hormones (such as ghrelin) and reducing satiety hormones (such as leptin). At the same time, metabolism often slows, meaning the body burns fewer calories at rest. These biological adaptations can persist long after weight loss occurs, making regain common and understandable, not a sign of failure.
Recognising obesity as a chronic condition rather than a character flaw helps shift the conversation from blame to support.
Genetics and Biology Play a Major Role
Genetics strongly influence body weight. Studies suggest that 40–70% of variation in body weight is heritable. Some people are biologically predisposed to store energy more efficiently, feel hunger more intensely, or experience satiety less strongly than others.
Brain imaging and hormonal research show that people with obesity often have differences in appetite regulation, reward pathways, and insulin signalling. These differences affect how food is perceived, how cravings form, and how difficult it can be to change eating behaviours, even when motivation is high.
Importantly, genetics do not determine destiny, but they do influence risk and response. Two people can follow the same lifestyle and experience very different outcomes.
The Environment Shapes Behaviour (Often Invisibly)
Modern environments make weight regulation more challenging for nearly everyone. Highly processed, calorie-dense foods are inexpensive, convenient, and aggressively marketed. At the same time, many communities lack access to affordable fresh foods, safe spaces for physical activity, or predictable work schedules that support regular meals and sleep.
Stress, whether financial, social, or emotional also plays a role. Chronic stress increases cortisol, a hormone linked to increased appetite and fat storage. Sleep deprivation, common in today’s fast-paced world, disrupts hunger hormones and insulin sensitivity, further increasing obesity risk.
These factors are not evenly distributed. Social determinants of health such as income, education, discrimination, and access to healthcare significantly influence obesity prevalence.
Addressing obesity therefore requires attention not just to individuals, but to systems.
Weight Is Not the Same as Health
Another important scientific insight is that body weight alone is an incomplete measure of health. People in larger bodies can have strong cardiovascular fitness, normal metabolic markers, and healthy behaviours. Conversely, people in smaller bodies may experience significant metabolic disease.
Health outcomes improve when the focus shifts from weight loss alone to sustainable behaviours: nourishing food patterns, regular movement, adequate sleep, stress management, and social connection. Even modest changes in these areas can yield meaningful health benefits, regardless of whether the scale changes.
The Harm of Weight Stigma
Weight stigma is not a neutral social issue; it has measurable health consequences. Research shows that individuals who experience weight bias are more likely to avoid medical care, engage in disordered eating, experience depression and anxiety, and gain additional weight over time.
Compassionate, respectful healthcare improves outcomes. When people feel safe and supported, they are more likely to seek care, follow medical guidance, and engage in long-term health behaviours.
Reducing stigma is not about ignoring health risks; it is about creating conditions where health can realistically improve.
A Science-Based, Compassionate Path Forward
Understanding the science behind obesity invites a more humane response. Effective approaches may include individualised nutrition counselling, psychological support, medications, surgery for appropriate candidates, and critically, long-term follow-up. No single solution works for everyone and expecting quick or permanent results from short-term interventions is inconsistent with what we know about human biology.
Equally important is how we speak about obesity. Language matters!
Empathy, curiosity, and respect allows science to be translated into care that honours lived experience.
Obesity is not a simple problem with a simple solution. It is a chronic condition shaped by biology, environment, and society. When we replace judgment with understanding and myths with evidence, we create space for real progress, both in individual health and in public health policy.
Compassion is not the opposite of science
In the case of obesity, compassion is what science clearly calls for.
At Verve Health Group we provide care that is evidence based, provided by clinicians who have many years of Weight Management experience, in both the NHS and private sectors.
We chose our team carefully to make sure that you will have the best experience of supportive healthcare, because we know that creates the best results.
Or send us a message